The Wilfred C. Molloy Award pays tribute to someone who has contributed to the Port Huron sports environment, not necessarily on the field of friendly competition, but in a manner which deserves special recognition. The award is in tribute to Mr. Molloy, one of the founders of the Port Huron Sports Hall of Fame.
Below is a list of those who have been honored by receiving this award.
| 1981 | Andrew J. Murphy |
| 1982 | Fred McElroy |
| 1983 | Herbert E. Rosine |
| 1984 | Robert McCalla |
| 1985 | Eugene H. Moak |
| 1986 | Dr. Charles O. Townley |
| 1987 | Helen David |
| 1988 | Harry C. Smith |
| 1989 | Jack S. Campbell |
| 1990 | Betty & Jack Vargo |
| 1991 | James R. Leonard |
| 1992 | London's Farm Dairy, Inc. |
| 1993 | Louis C. Petho III |
| 1994 | Thomas Clark |
| 1995 | James Earl Jones |
| Lew Secory | |
| 1996 | Al Shady |
| 1997 | Kevin Zaborney |
| Jon Howard | |
| 1998 | Pat Hills |
| 1999 | Charlie Cook |
| 2000 | Terry Ruff |
| 2001 | Don & Gayle Nabozney |
| 2002 | Markus Schulz |
| 2003 | John F. (Jerry) Brown |
| 2004 | George Udell |
| 2005 | Dr. Gary Doss |
| 2006 | Mark Duncan |
| 2007 | Bill Harris |
| 2008 | Tyrone Burrell |
| 2009 | Ralph Bopra |
| Bob Crawford | |
| 2010 | Mike Cruickshank |
| 2011 | Dave Speilburg |
| 2012 | Salvation Army Youth Basketball Program |
| 2013 | Dr. Alexander Ruthven |
| 2014 | Virginia “Ginny” Irland |
| 2015 | Miles "Mike" Benedict |
| 2016 | Judge David Nicholson |
| 2017 | Tyrone Burrell |
| 2018 | Paul Jones Sr. |
| 2019 | Darlene Peterson |
| 2020 | No award due to COVID-19 |
| 2021 | Linda Taylor |
| 2022 | John Bacheller |
| 2023 | Joe Szczepkowski |
| 2024 | Port Huron Yacht Club |
| 2025 | Jim McPhee |